Stocking Stuffers Under $5!

Filter
    137 products
    Flamingo Can Cover Coozie
    'I Don't Give A Flock' Drink Hugger
    $4.99
    Sale
    Classic White Pearl Stud Earrings by Prep Obsessed
    Classic White Pearl Stud Earrings- 2 Sizes Available
    $9.99 from $4.99
    Chocolate Bunny Scented Pen
    $4.00
    Mystery Initial Necklace
    $2.00
    Donut Scented Pen
    $4.00
    Eras Friendship Bracelets Sticker
    $4.00
    Sticker Decals by Simply Southern
    $2.99
    Sale
    Santa Spiked Seltzer Beaded Dangle Earrings
    $19.99 $1.00
    Mystery State Jewelry
    $2.00
    Ice Cream Scented Pen
    $4.00
    Car Coasters by Simply Southern
    $3.99
    Sale
    Gold Glitter Varsity Letter Patch - Hot Pink
    $7.99 $2.00
    Sale
    Gold Glitter Varsity Letter Patch - Creme
    $7.99 $2.00
    Sale
    'When Life Gives You Pineapples, Make Pina Coladas' Drink Hugger
    $4.99 $0.50
    Sale
    'Another Awesome Year' Balloon Shaped Party Napkins
    $9.99 $2.00
    Our Favorite Lip Balm - Birthday Cake
    $4.99
    'Start Carving, We're Starving' Drink Hugger by Prep Obsessed
    $4.99
    Sale
    Gold Glitter Varsity Letter Patch - Mint
    $7.99 $2.00
    Pumpkin Card Holders by Mud Pie - 3 Color Options
    $4.99
    Yankee Candle Car Jar - Coconut Beach
    $3.50
    Sale
    Smart Watch Band Stud - Be Mine
    $7.99 $4.00
    Mini Thinking Putty - Rock n Roll
    $4.00
    Sale
    Hot Chocolate Bomb Signature Enamel Stud
    $9.99 $1.00
    Our Favorite Lip Balm - Honey
    Our Favorite Lip Balm - Honey
    $4.99
    Sale
    Softball Printed Slim Can Drink Hugger
    $5.99 $2.50
    Glitter Gel Scented Pens
    $3.99
    Disney Donald Duck Good Times Sticker by Pura Vida
    $3.50
    Modern Monkey Tentacle Tech Suction Phone Mount
    $4.99
    Sale
    Smart Watch Band Stud - XOXO
    $7.99 $4.00
    Mini Games Club - Bigger, Taller, Smaller
    $4.99
    Disney Daisy Duck Lounging Sticker by Pura Vida
    $3.50
    Bistro Fridge Magnet Sets by Mud Pie
    $4.00
    'Women Belong In All Places Where Decisions Are Being Made' Drink Hugger
    $4.99
    ONE DOLLAR Mystery Jewelry
    $1.00
    Mystery Hair Accessories by Prep Obsessed (Ships in 2-3 Weeks)
    from $3.50
    Disney Donald Duck Cali Dreaming Sticker by Pura Vida
    $3.50
    Favorite Tropes Bookshelf Sticker
    $3.99
    Sale
    Watercolor Cactus Cutout
    $9.99 $4.99
    'Praying for You' Greeting Card
    $4.50
    'Books Are My Love Language' Sticker
    $3.99
    'Team Bride' Mini Greeting Card
    $4.00
    Fuzz Off Dermaplaner Facial Razors
    $4.99
    'But the Greatest Of These Is Love' Greeting Card
    $4.50
    Sale
    Rainbow Party Toniebox Topper
    $7.99 $3.99
    Sticker by Simply Southern
    $3.99
    Sale
    Nautical Silicone Shoe Charm Set
    $7.99 $2.50
    by PrepO: Patriotic Fireworks Doodle Dog - Decal by Prep Obsessed (Ships in 2-3 Weeks)
    $4.99
    Shopping Cart Quarter Saver Keychain
    $3.99
    Spring Scented Pencils
    $2.99
    'Only As Pretty As You Treat People' Sticker
    $4.00
    Oklahoma State Sticker
    $4.00
    Americana Bow Sticker
    $3.99
    Mini Masterpieces - Luncheon of the Boating Party
    $3.99
    'Finish Your TBR' Sticker
    $3.99
    'Mi Taco es Mi Taco' Sticker
    $4.00
    'Commas Are Important' Sticker
    $4.00
    'There Are Two Types Of People' Sticker
    $4.00
    Mississippi State Sticker
    $4.00
    White insulated tumbler with raccoon reading a book and ‘Booktrovert’ design
    by PrepO: 'Booktrovert' Raccoon 3" Decal by Prep Obsessed (Ships in 2-3 Weeks)
    $4.99
    Black insulated tumbler with the text 'Book Lover' in a floral knit-style design with an open book and pink flowers
    by PrepO: Book Lover 3" Decal by Prep Obsessed (Ships in 2-3 Weeks)
    $4.99
    Sale
    Strawberry Shortcake Cocktail Napkins by Swig
    $5.95 $4.95
    Mini Library Jigsaw - Little Women
    $3.99
    Mini Masterpieces - Vase of Flowers
    $3.99
    by PrepO: Patriotic Chicken - Decal by Prep Obsessed (Ships in 2-3 Weeks)
    $4.99
    Disney Stitch Metal Clip Pen
    $4.99
    Mini Masterpieces - Squares With Concentric Circles
    $3.99
    Mini Library Jigsaw - Jane Eyre
    $3.99
    'I'd Rather Be Someone's Shot Of Tequila Than Everyone's Cup Of Tea' Sticker
    $4.00
    'Partyboob' Sticker
    $4.00
    'The Difference Between Tequila And Your Opinion' Sticker
    $4.00
    'Laughter Is The Best Medicine. Or Queso' Sticker
    $4.00
    'Will You Be My Maid of Honor' Wedding Day Card
    'Will You Be My Maid of Honor' Wedding Day Card
    $2.95
    Sale
    Flamingos Cocktail Napkins by Swig
    $5.95 $4.95
    Pink insulated tumbler with ‘Prep Obsessed est 2013’ text design in pink and green
    by PrepO: Pink & Green Prep Obsessed 3" Decal by Prep Obsessed (Ships in 2-3 Weeks)
    $4.99
    Bye Bye Blackheads 3-Step Nose Cleansing Treatment
    $4.99
    Sale
    Lemon Meringue Cocktail Napkins by Swig
    $5.95 $4.95
    Coastal Sticker by Simply Southern
    $4.99
    Gingham Shamrock Magnet by Roeda
    $3.99
    Pineapple Magnet by Roeda
    $3.99
    by PrepO: Margarita Weather Decal (Ships in 1-2 Weeks)
    $4.99